Enea: Pessimism toward 5G potential

Research Update

2023-04-28

07:25

Redeye thinks the Q1 report was weak, but in line with Redeye's expectations. The telecom segment of Network Solutions is not developing according to Enea's expectations, causing Enea to initiate a strategic review of its telecom portfolio. The company aims to focus on the growing parts and that profitability is key. Redeye thinks Enea is looking to divest one or several of its 5G products. Redeye lowers its fair value range.

JVK

Jesper Von Koch

Poor quarter from the telecom part of Network Solutions

Sales from Network Solutions declined by 8% y/y, or by 13% currency adjusted. The telecom segment is struggling in a tough market while cyber security is developing well. The continuous decline in Operating Systems is causing a deteriorating group profitability, likely to be visual from Q2 and onwards.

Strategic review in Q2 - to evaluate 5G portfolio

Low sales and high R&D costs for Enea's 5G portfolio have caused the company to initiate a strategic review. The company states that it will focus on the growing parts and that profitability is key. Our interpretation of this is that one or a few of Enea’s 5G products are intended to be sold in the reasonably near future.

Trading around our Bear Case - pessimism towards the remaining revenue base

The uncertainty around Enea's 5G portfolio makes us lower our estimates for Network solutions by 7-9% for 2023-2025E, resulting in lower profitability. Enea's share price has taken a big blow since it lost its large 5G contract awarded in 2020. This signals that investors believe this is not a one-time thing and have started to doubt the strength of Enea's offering. Redeye lowers its fair value range with a new Base Case at SEK96 (SEK120), Bear Case at SEK58 (SEK67), and Bull Case at SEK166 (SEK190),

Key financials

SEKm202120222023e2024e2025e
Revenues993.5959.4953.3933.01,011.2
Revenue Growth6.9%-3.4%-0.6%-2.1%8.4%
EBITDA375.2292.4262.7255.7288.2
EBIT214.3117.972.765.799.4
EBIT Margin21.6%12.3%7.6%7.0%9.8%
Net Income198.6203.131.630.657.3
EV/Revenue6.11.81.91.81.6
EV/EBIT28.415.024.525.916.2
P/E26.513.546.147.625.4

Review of Q1'23

Total revenue was SEK 248m, +18% Y/Y (+13% FX adjusted), mainly driven by a one-off license fee in Operating Systems of SEK54m. This was slightly above our estimates of SEK240m. Higher revenues from Operating Systems explain the deviation. EBIT was SEK47m, corresponding to an EBIT margin of 19% (-4% last year). This was 10% above our estimates of SEK43m. Important to note is that without the one-off license fee in Operating Systems (which is otherwise almost purely recurring), EBIT would be negative.

Enea: Estimates vs Actuals
SEKmQ1'23AQ1'23ELast yearBeat/ Missy/y changeFX adj. Org. Growth
Net sales2482402113%18%13%
- of which Network Solutions1641631781%-8%-13%
- of which Operating Systems8477339%153%
Gross margin80%80%71%0%12%
EBITDA94863910%143%
EBIT4743-910%-627%
EBIT margin19%18%-4%

Top line: Network Solutions declining, and relative strength from Operating Systems

Network Solutions: Weak from the telecom part but solid from cyber security

Sales from Network Solutions declined by 8% y/y, or by 13% currency adjusted. The y/y drop can be explained, as we indicated in our preview, by not including any new license contracts in the quarter. While Enea does not provide a detailed development between cyber security and telecom, it is clear from Enea that telecom is struggling while cyber security is developing well.

Due to the seasonal pattern in Network Solutions, with Q2 typically being bigger than Q1, Q3 bigger than Q2, and Q4 bigger than Q3, we provide a quarterly comparison diagram below.

Enea: Network Solutions, SEKm

Source: Enea

Network Solutions: Development per revenue type

The y/y decline in Network Solutions was caused by y/y declines of both Licenses and Professional Services. License revenues declined from SEK80m to cSEK58m, while Professional Services declined from cSEK43m to cSEK36m. As previously stated, the revenue mix of Network Solutions is much less steady than that of the steady flow of royalty fees in Operating Systems.

The revenue mix of Network Solutions can be seen below:

Source: Enea

Operating Systems: Boosted by one-off license fee but also underlying strength

Sales from Operating Systems was boosted by a one-off license fee of EUR4.8m (cSEK54) in the quarter. This was from one of the two key accounts (Nokia and Ericsson) that renegotiated its contract - from a recurring license fee to a one-off license fee followed by minor maintenance fees. We commented on this news here. Sales came in at SEK84m, or cSEK30m excluding the one-off. This was SEK7m better than we had estimated. We think the underlying beat originated from one or a few smaller customers completing system upgrades in the quarter. Hence, we believe the underlying base of recurring revenues is rather around SEK23m.

Enea: Operating Systems, SEKm

Source: Enea

Gross margin: Strong due to one-off license fee

Gross margin landed at 80% (excluding “other operating income”), compared to 75% for full-year 2022 and 71% in Q1 last year. The one-off license fee from Operating Systems contributed positively, while the lower license revenues in Network Solutions contributed negatively.

Enea: Gross margin

Source: Enea

The seasonal pattern of license revenues being stronger the farther into the financial year implies that Q1 will have a much higher share of service revenue (with lower gross margin) than all other quarters, but especially compared to Q4. To illustrate the seasonality, see the below diagram for the same figures:

Enea: Quarterly y/y comparison of gross margin

Source: Enea

Cost base: Solid level - resources moved from R&D to sales

Reported OPEX, incl. D&A, was SEK150m, and “clean” OPEX (excl. D&A) was SEK109m. “Other operating income” consists of revaluation of the incentive program and FX-related revaluations of accounts receivable, meaning that we consider this a one-off. This means that the underlying OPEX is SEK109m. This level has been relatively stable over the last four quarters.

Enea: OPEX (excl. D&A), SEKm

Source: Enea

Outlook: Aiming for unchanged topline and EBITDA vs 2022

Enea states that it sees significant uncertainty in the global environment and challenges in the telecom market that will affect Enea’s business. Enea aims for revenues and EBITDA in line with last year, implying revenues of SEK959m and EBITDA of SEK292. This aligns with our estimates on topline but with higher profitability.

Financial position: Strong financial position that keeps improving

Net debt/EBITDA at 0.8

With SEK521m in interest-bearing debt and SEK258m in cash, net debt is at SEK263m. Compared with LTM EBITDA of SEK348m, we get net debt/EBITDA at 0.8.

Capital allocation: Room for M&A, but perhaps not the short-term focus

Assuming a conservative ceiling of Net Debt/EBITDA of 2.0, we think Enea can make acquisitions worth SEK 350m. Considering the LTM EBITDA, there is even more room, but we think the current level is temporarily boosted by the one-off license fee in Operating Systems this quarter.

Considering the current negative market sentiment, with valuations coming down also on the private market, we deem it possible to acquire a company at a multiple of 2.5x sales, which would add around SEK140m to Enea’s revenue base, or around 15% to total sales.

However, considering that Enea will complete a strategic review in Q2 (see below), we think the company’s focus is elsewhere.

Strategic review in Q2 - to evaluate 5G portfolio

In the report, Enea stated that it would conduct a strategic review of its telecom business of Network Solutions in Q2. Enea explains that the telecom market is challenging, with operators running with heightened OPEX (e.g., high energy costs) and financial costs. This causes telcos to push investments into the future and instead "sweat use" the last bit of their existing technology. This has implied that moving to the new architecture for 5G (5G stand-alone) has taken longer than anticipated. This, in turn, has resulted in too few customers investing in Enea’s 5G portfolio.

Low sales and high R&D costs for Enea’s 5G portfolio have caused the company to initiate a strategic review. Enea states that it will focus on the growing parts and that profitability is key. Our interpretation of this is that one or a few of Enea’s 5G products are intended to be sold in the reasonably near future.

Changes to financial estimates

  • Lowering annual estimates for Network Solutions by 5-10%
  • Minor estimate changes for Operating Systems
  • Lowering gross margin estimates by one percentage point for 2024E-2025E
  • OPEX lowered by c2% for 2023E-2025E
  • EBITDA lowered by c20% for 2023E-2025E
  • EBIT lowered by c50% for 2023E-2025E due to lower estimates for high-margin license fees and higher D&A
  • Our estimated terminal EBIT margin is reduced from 22% to 18%

Estimate changes

SEKm20212022Q1 23Q2 23EQ3 23EQ4 23E2023E2024E2025E2026E
Total net sales994959248
New2122262689539331,0111097
Old2262402839681,0301,090
Change-6%-6%-6%-2%-9%-7%
Gross margin79%75%80%
New75%76%77%77%76%76%77%
Old76%77%79%77%77%77%
Change0%0%-1%-1%-2%0%-1%-1%0%
OPEX434463109
New153109109471452479506
Old
Change
EBITDA37529294
New66397263256288337
Old6171110305328353
Change-90%-12%-12%-14%-22%-18%
EBIT21411847
New-411650736699149
Old182967130153174
Change-322%-45%-26%-44%-57%-43%
EBIT (%)22%12%19%
New-19%7%19%8%7%10%14%
Old8%12%24%13%15%16%
Change-27%-5%-5%-6%-8%-6%0%

Estimate changes per business segment

SEKm20212022Q1 23Q2 23EQ3 23EQ4 23E2023E2024E2025E2026E
Network Solutions727802164
New1892062428018499341,027
Old1992162548589351,010
Change-5%-5%-5%-7%-9%-8%
Operating Systems13712684
New232026152847770
Old2220251448276
Change3%3%3%6%2%2%

Financial estimates overview

SEKm20212022Q1 23Q2 23EQ3 23EQ4 23E2023E2024E2025E2026E
Net sales9949592482122262689539331,0111,097
- Network Solutions7278021641892062428018499341,027
- Operating Systems13712684232026152847770
EBITDA3752929466397263256288337
EBIT21411847-411650736699149
EPS (SEK)9.249.290.47-1.720.321.571.441.402.624.41
Free cash flow016349-172855117116142181
Growth (%)7%-3%2%-2%-2%-1%-1%-2%8%8%
Gross margin79%75%80%75%76%77%77%76%76%77%
EBITDA margin (%)38%30%38%3%28%36%28%27%28%31%
EBIT margin (%)22%12%19%-19%7%19%8%7%10%14%
Free cash flow margin (%)0%18%5%-2%3%6%13%13%15%19%
Net income margin (%)20%11%4%-18%3%13%3%3%6%9%

Fair value range

Assumptions, fair value range
Bear CaseBase caseBull case
Value per share, SEK5896166
CAGR 2022-2027 per segment
Network Solutions4%6%8%
Operating Systems-15%-13%-11%
Total2%4%6%
Total sales 20271,0451,1521,378
EBIT margin 202713%15%19%
Avg EBIT margin 2023-20279%11%15%
Terminal EBIT margin11%18%22%
WACC10.5%10.5%10.5%

Investment thesis

Case

Scalable software company with market-leading positions in 5G and cybersecurity

Enea has a long history of pioneering the telecom industry - at the beginning, through consulting and then through software and service offerings. Since 2016, the company has made a significant transition. Enea has moved from being a software company in Operating Systems towards mainly Nokia and Ericsson, with consulting on top, to having sold its consulting leg and replaced Operating Systems with a new forward-tilted business unit - Network Solutions. The new Enea constitutes a group of leading niche software for 5G and cybersecurity. Enea has historically strong EBIT margins exceeding 20% and healthy growth. In recent years, the organic growth in Network Solutions has slowed down, and the resulting profitability has declined. Should Enea regain its organic growth as the rollout of 5G takes off, there is ample room in the company’s valuation. On top of this, Enea has since 2016 completed about one acquisition per year. Further acquisitions will further help Enea's growth journey.

Evidence

Customers moving from large one-stop-shops to best-of-breed solutions

Historically, customers have chosen large one-stop-shop providers like Ericsson. Thus, a wide product portfolio has been an important competitive edge. Now, customers are starting to choose best-of-breed solutions from various providers, which together add up to a complete offering. This is a large benefiter for the likes of Enea.

Challenge

Low organic growth in the 'growth leg' and profitability below 20% for the first time in many years

While Enea has gone through a challenging transition period, moving from Operating Systems to Network Solutions, Enea has struggled to obtain organic growth in Network Solutions. This is despite paying rather high valuation multiples for its acquisitions. Since 2016, we assess organic growth in Network Solutions to have been around 5%. The poor organic growth and a slowly growing cost base have resulted in a trailing 12-month EBIT margin not exceeding Enea’s 20% target for the first time in many years.

Challenge

Uncertainty around the rollout of 5G

Enea states that it will benefit from the change from 4G to 5G - while 5G will drive new income streams, it does not expect 4G revenues to be held up by less developed markets going from 2G or 3G to 4G. Regarding 5G, Enea will participate in the ‘core network’ buildout, which implies the latter part of the rollout. 5G has been substantially delayed compared to industry expectations, so Enea’s 5G investments have not yet paid off. If or when it does, Enea is likely to regain its former margins and growth rates.

Valuation

Depressed share price does not include any market tailwind from 5G

Enea’s share price has taken a brutal hit lately, tumbling from around SEK280 to today’s level of around SEK70. Partly, we think this is because the company has revealed a lower share of reliable recurring revenue than investors previously anticipated. However, today’s share price doesn’t include any 5G-related growth. The rollout of 5G has barely started for Enea’s account, as the company is mainly exposed to the 5G core network. Enea has been honest about being too early with its efforts to prepare itself for 5G exposure. However, the early attempts have been the right ones, but macroeconomic factors have delayed the rollout. Enea is currently conducting a strategic review of its 5G portfolio, possibly resulting in either selling parts of it or changing it in another way.

Quality Rating

People: 3

The Board has extensive experience in telecom and software. The CEO, Jan Häglund, has 25 years of experience working with technologies from Enea or similar at Ericsson. We like that Enea's communication addresses risk openly. Per Lindberg, Enea's main owner (34% of total shares), has a deep understanding of the telecom industry. However, Management and the Board do not own enough shares as they together do not even control 1% of the company. On the top 10 owners, we find several reputable institutions, though. Enea has since 2016 made approximately one acquisition per year. While Enea has paid quite hefty valuation multiples, the growth rate since these acquisitions has been in the mid-single digit. This puts a question mark on capital allocation skills.

Business: 4

The markets for RTOS as well as DPI, video optimization, and policy and access control are mirroring the strong growth of data traffic from 5G and the increased number of connected devices. Enea is the number one player in its niche telecom markets: RTOS, DPI, and mobile video. Despite the challenges from the open source towards Operating Systems, Enea has a strong position in telecom as the majority of all base stations globally depend on Enea software. Enea has partnerships with big players like e.g. Ericsson and Nokia, plus 8 of the 10 largest telecom operators. The scalable software business model means gross margins above 75%. The risky, high Key Accounts (Nokia & Ericsson) exposure has decreased a lot from the acquisitions of Qosmos, Openwave, Atos, Aptilo, and AdaptiveMobile Security.

Financials: 3

For the first time in many years, the trailing-12-month EBIT margin does not exceed Enea's 20% target. While Enea has gone through a tough transition period, moving from Operating Systems to Network Solution, we are not impressed by Enea's organic growth. Since 2016, we assess this to have been around 5%. Also, the company's revenue base has become bumpy and unpredictable due to a lower share of recurring license revenues. For a higher rating, we need a clearer way towards organic growth in the high single digits, at least.

Financials

Income statement
SEKm202120222023e2024e2025e
Revenues993.5959.4953.3933.01,011.2
Cost of Revenue350.8241.6219.5225.3244.2
Operating Expenses267.5425.4471.2452.0478.9
EBITDA375.2292.4262.7255.7288.2
Depreciation15.012.414.014.014.0
Amortizations145.9146.8158.8158.8158.8
EBIT214.3117.972.765.799.4
Shares in Associates0.000.000.000.000.00
Interest Expenses-5.231.727.327.327.3
Net Financial Items5.2-17.3-27.3-27.3-27.3
EBT219.5100.645.438.572.1
Income Tax Expenses20.9-7.413.97.914.9
Net Income198.6203.131.630.657.3
Balance sheet
Assets
Non-current assets
SEKm202120222023e2024e2025e
Property, Plant and Equipment (Net)25.621.57.5-6.5-20.5
Goodwill1,595.61,737.11,737.11,737.11,737.1
Intangible Assets717.8756.6729.4702.2675.0
Right-of-Use Assets0.000.00-17.2-34.4-50.4
Other Non-Current Assets29.026.026.026.026.0
Total Non-Current Assets2,368.02,541.22,482.82,424.42,367.2
Current assets
SEKm202120222023e2024e2025e
Inventories0.000.000.000.000.00
Accounts Receivable454.0545.4381.3373.2404.5
Other Current Assets0.000.000.000.000.00
Cash Equivalents211.4231.3220.2295.0387.9
Total Current Assets665.4776.7601.5668.2792.4
Total Assets3,033.43,317.93,084.33,092.63,159.6
Equity and Liabilities
Equity
SEKm202120222023e2024e2025e
Non Controlling Interest0.000.000.000.000.00
Shareholder's Equity1,778.02,295.72,225.72,240.52,282.5
Non-current liabilities
SEKm202120222023e2024e2025e
Long Term Debt469.8545.1545.1545.1545.1
Long Term Lease Liabilities43.017.017.017.017.0
Other Long Term Liabilities124.3139.7139.7139.7139.7
Total Non-Current Liabilities637.1701.8701.8701.8701.8
Current liabilities
SEKm202120222023e2024e2025e
Short Term Debt268.8305.8305.8305.8305.8
Short Term Lease Liabilities16.914.514.514.514.5
Accounts Payable0.000.00114.4112.0121.3
Other Current Liabilities332.40.00190.7186.6202.2
Total Current Liabilities618.1320.3625.4618.9643.9
Total Liabilities and Equity3,033.23,317.83,552.93,561.23,628.1
Cash flow
SEKm202120222023e2024e2025e
Operating Cash Flow340.5422.4222.0222.2239.8
Investing Cash Flow-414.1-136.5-131.6-131.6-131.6
Financing Cash Flow0.00-99.3-101.6-15.8-15.3

Rating definitions

The team

Disclosures and disclaimers

Premium Plan required to unlock

Unlock companies to access

more high quality research.