Bredband2: Margin improvements

Research Update

2023-08-10

07:45

Redeye makes minor forecast changes following Bredband2’s Q2 2023 report, in which sales came in slightly above our expectations, which, coupled with lower operating expenses, resulted in higher-than-expected margins. Accordingly, the updated forecast has a slightly upwards effect on our fair value range.

JS

FN

Jacob Svensson

Fredrik Nilsson

Contents

Review of Q2 2023

Sales: Slightly stronger than expected

Customer intake, ARPC and gross margin

OPEX: Continue to decrease as a percentage of sales

Profitability: Improved margins that are expected to continue

Estimate changes

Valuation – New Base Case of SEK2.0 (1.9)

Investment thesis

Quality Rating

Financials

Rating definitions

The team

Download article

Q2 2023: Higher-than-expected sales and margins

Q2 2023 net sales amounted to 392.7m (382.7m), corresponding to a 2.6% y/y growth and were slightly above our expectations of SEK385.8m. Despite a slightly lower gross margin than expected, 33.7% (35.0%), versus the expected 34.2%, lower OPEX upheld this, which resulted in higher-than-expected margins. The EBITDA and EBIT amounted to SEK61.9m (59.2m) and SEK26.1m (21.1m), 4% and 11% above our expectations, respectively. Consequently, the EBITDA margin was 15.8% (15.5%) versus the estimated 15.4%, while the EBIT margin came in at 6.6% (5.5%) compared to the expected 6.1%.

Continued execution of margin-enhancement efforts

The improved margins y/y stem from continued margin prioritising, which is expected to continue, as Bredband2 reiterated its aspirations to improve the EBIT margin by c1pp to Q4 2023. As such, we state that the higher-than-expected margins in Q2 2023 indicated continued execution of margin-enhancement efforts, which we appreciate seeing. Despite management’s expectations of a temporary softer customer intake, we note the net customer intake of zero in the quarter as solid concerning recent margin prioritising and price hikes. Moreover, management expects increased sales during the remainder of 2023, both within its private and corporate segments.

New fair value range, with a Base Case of SEK2.0 (1.9)

We make minor 2023e and 2024e forecast adjustments on the back of Bredband2’s Q2 2023 report. We raise our sales forecasts by 1%–2% for 2023e–2024e while we trim our gross margin assumptions slightly. However, a lowered OPEX offset this, leading to a 4% increased EBIT forecast for the period. As such, our DCF model yields a new Base Case of SEK2.0 (1.9) per share and Bear and Bull Cases of SEK1.1 (1.0) and SEK2.6 (2.5), respectively. Currently, Bredband2 is trading at an EV/EBIT of 10.7x based on our 2023e and an EV/EBITA of 8.2x.

Key financials

SEKm2020202120222023e2024e
Revenues787.91,511.91,531.41,567.41,609.9
Revenue Growth17.5%91.9%1.3%2.4%2.7%
EBITDA79.4219.5241.3251.7271.0
EBIT42.893.994.8109.4130.1
EBIT Margin5.4%6.2%6.2%7.0%8.1%
Net Income30.981.272.977.593.8
EV/Revenue2.61.30.80.70.7
EV/EBIT47.521.713.110.78.6

Review of Q2 2023

Q2 2023 net sales amounted to 392.7m (382.7m), corresponding to a 2.6% y/y growth and was 2% above our expectations of SEK385.8m. The number of broadband customers via fibre amounted to c456,000 (459,000), implying a net customer intake of zero in the quarter, while the gross margin was 33.7% (35.0%), somewhat below our expectations of 34.2%.

Despite the slightly stronger sales than our expectations, the softer gross margin made the gross profit largely align with our estimate. However, OPEX improvements offset this, leaving EBITDA and EBIT above our expectations. EBITDA and EBIT came in at SEK61.9m (59.2m) and SEK26.1m (21.1m), implying an EBITDA 4% above our expectations, while EBIT came in 11% above. Consequently, the EBITDA margin was 15.8% (15.5%) versus our estimated 15.4%, while the EBIT margin came in at 6.6% (5.5%) compared with our expectation of 6.1%.

According to management, the improved margins y/y stem from the recent increased focus on margins, which is expected to continue having a positive effect, with expectations of an improved EBIT margin by c1pp to Q4 2023. However, the margin-enhancement efforts will probably have a temporary short-term negative impact on customer intake for private fibre services in the coming months. Moreover, management expects increased sales during the remainder of 2023, both within its private and corporate segments.

Bredband2: Estimates versus actuals
SEKmQ2 23eQ2 23aDiffQ2 22Q1 23
Net sales385.8392.72%382.7383.1
Growth y/y (%)0.8%2.6%0.6%-0.1%
Gross profit131.9132.30%134.1129.7
Gross margin (%)34.2%33.7%35.0%33.9%
Total OPEX-72.4-70.5-3%-74.9-69.3
Growth y/y (%)-3.2%-5.9%-2.1%-6.2%
EBITDA59.561.94%59.260.4
EBITDA margin (%)15.4%15.8%15.5%15.8%
EBIT23.426.111%21.125.0
EBIT margin (%)6.1%6.6%5.5%6.5%
EPS, diluted0.020.0211%0.010.02
Source: Redeye Research (estimates), Bredband2 (historical data)

Sales: Slightly stronger than expected

Q2 2023 net sales amounted to 392.7m (382.7m), corresponding to a 2.6% y/y growth and were 2% above our expectations of SEK385.8m. According to management, the increase in sales, both sequentially and y/y, is mainly a result of recent price hikes within its private segment, while bredband2 has won some new contracts within its corporate segment.

Moreover, management expects increased sales during the remainder of 2023, both within its private and corporate segments, with continued price hikes implemented gradually until September 2023. As such, we believe this can support increased sales ahead.

Bredband2: Net sales and y/y growth

Source: Redeye Research, Bredband2

Notably, the growth peak in Q4 2020-Q4 2021 is mainly acquired, as A3 was consolidated from December 2020.

Customer intake, ARPC and gross margin

Total broadband customers via fibre amounted to c456,000 (459,000), implying a net customer intake of zero in the quarter. While a net customer of zero does not sound that impressive at first glance, we find it solid concerning Bredband2’s recent margin-enchanting efforts coupled with recent price hikes, which, all else equal, should give rise to an increased customer churn. In addition, we want to highlight that management has been clear and transparent about the temporarily softer customer intake in the wake of Bredband2’s current margin prioritising phase. As such, we find it natural to expect a somewhat softer net customer intake during the remainder of 2023.

ARPC amounted to cSEK218 per month and increased by approximately 3% y/y. Notably, as Bredband2 discloses its total number of broadband customers via fibre, this includes both private and corporate customers. Nevertheless, we have chosen to use ARPC based on private sales and the total number of customers despite including a share of corporate customers. Although this is not an entirely true definition, we use it here as a benchmark since Bredband2 does not disclose its private customer base separately. Moreover, its private customers are its most substantial customer segment, while we believe its corporate customers account for a minor share of its total customers.

Bredband2: Number of customers and ARPC/month

Source: Redeye Research, Bredband2

Together with ARPC, net customer intake is the most important metric for Bredband2. Strong net customer intake could imply a low churn or that Bredband2 covers up well with a solid gross customer intake, which we believe is important to gain/retain market share in an industry where scale matters. However, the fibre market is starting to mature, likely resulting in lower net customer intake ahead, leaving ARPC as the primary sales growth driver. Strong ARPC growth implies the average customer uses additional services or that Bredband2 manages to hike prices. While price hikes should negatively influence net customer intake, we believe additional services could raise customers switching costs, which, all else being equal, should reduce customer churn.

As mentioned, the gross margin in Q2 2023 was 33.7% and thus decreased y/y (35.0%) and sequentially from 33.9% in Q1 2023. We believe the gross margin has mainly been affected by network owners’ price hikes. According to management, the most substantial part of that is behind us, while Bredband2 expect further price hikes, which we believe can support the gross margin ahead. However, Bredband2 expects the EBIT margin improvements until Q4 2023 to mainly derive from OPEX improvements. Consequently, we expect relatively stable gross margins in H2 2023, with a slight increase in Q4 as implemented price adjustments have taken full effect.

Bredband2: Net customer intake and gross margin

Source: Redeye Research, Bredband2

Notably, Q4 2020 and Q1 2022 figures in the graph above include acquired customers from A3 and TH1NG, which saw more significant increases than the y-axis spans.

OPEX: Continue to decrease as a percentage of sales

Total OPEX amounted to SEK70.5m (74.9m) in the quarter and came in 3% below our forecast of SEK72.4m, decreasing c6% y/y. Accordingly, Bredband2’s total OPEX continue to decrease as a percentage of sales, from 19.2% in Q2 2022 to 17.9% in Q2 2023. We believe this again highlights Bredbands2’s internal efficiency improvements, which we have seen historically.

Bredband2: OPEX distribution

Source: Redeye Research, Bredband2

Profitability: Improved margins that are expected to continue

EBITDA was SEK61.9m (SEK59.2m), corresponding to an EBITDA margin of 15.8% (15.5%), compared with our expectations of SEKK59.5m and 15.4%, respectively. At the same time, EBIT amounted to SEK26.1m (SEK21.1m), which resulted in an EBIT margin of 6.6% (5.5%), compared with our forecast of SEK23.4m and 6.1%.

The improved margins stem from continued margin prioritising and OPEX improvements seen in the quarter, which is expected to continue, as Bredband2 reiterated its aspiration to improve the EBIT margin by c1pp to Q4 2023. As such, the Q2 2023 margin outcome indicated continued execution of this plan, which we appreciate seeing while it bodes well for continued margin improvements ahead.

Bredband2: Net sales, EBITDA margin and EBIT margin

Source: Redeye Research, Bredband2

Estimate changes

Following Bredband2’s Q2 2023 report, we make minor 2023e and 2024e forecast changes. We increase our sales forecast by 1%-2% for 2023e–2024e, implying 2.4% (1.1%) and 2.7% (2.3%) y/y growth, respectively. This stems mainly from management’s expected increased sales during the remainder of 2023 and continued price hikes implemented gradually until September 2023, which we believe can support increased sales ahead. Moreover, Bredband2 has stated an increased organic growth focus in H2 2023–H1 2024, leading us to expect slightly stronger growth in the latter part of 2023e and into 2024e.

In addition, we trim our 2023e–2024e gross margin assumptions while we decrease our OPEX forecasts somewhat for the same period on account of ongoing cost improvements seen in Q2 2023, which we expect to continue, backed by management’s statement of continued margin prioritising ahead. Altogether, this gives rise to a 4% increased EBIT forecast for 2023e–2024e. For further estimates, see the tables below.

Bredband2: Estimate revisions
SEKm2023eOldChange2024eOldChange
Net sales1567.41548.31%1609.91583.92%
Growth y/y (%)2.4%1.1%2.7%2.3%
Gross profit530.7530.90%557.0552.41%
Gross margin (%)33.9%34.3%34.6%34.9%
Total OPEX-279.1-281.8-1%-286.1-290.5-2%
Growth y/y (%)-5.3%-4.3%2.5%3.1%
EBITDA251.7249.11%271.0261.93%
EBITDA margin (%)16.1%16.1%16.8%16.5%
EBIT109.4104.74%130.1125.64%
EBIT margin (%)7.0%6.8%8.1%7.9%
EPS, diluted0.080.083%0.100.095%
Source: Redeye Research
Bredband2: Financial forecast
SEKm2022Q1 23Q2 23Q3 23eQ4 23e2023e2024e2025e
Net sales1,531.4383.1392.7394.6397.01,567.41,609.91,651.8
Growth y/y (%)1.3%-0.1%2.6%3.2%3.7%2.4%2.7%2.6%
Gross profit535.8129.7132.3133.4135.4530.7557.0575.2
Gross margin (%)35.0%33.9%33.7%33.8%34.1%33.9%34.6%34.8%
Total OPEX-294.6-69.3-70.5-69.4-70.0-279.1-286.1-297.9
Growth y/y (%)-6.2%-6.2%-5.9%-5.6%-3.3%-5.3%2.5%4.1%
EBITDA241.360.461.964.065.4251.7271.0277.3
EBITDA margin (%)15.8%15.8%15.8%16.2%16.5%16.1%16.8%16.8%
EBIT94.825.026.128.529.8109.4130.1141.9
EBIT margin (%)6.2%6.5%6.6%7.2%7.5%7.0%8.1%8.6%
EPS, diluted0.080.020.020.020.020.080.100.11
Source: Redeye Research (estimates), Bredband2 (historical data)

Valuation – New Base Case of SEK2.0 (1.9)

Following the estimate changes mentioned above, our DCF model yields a new Base Case of SEK2.0 (1.9) per share and Bear and Bull Cases of SEK1.1 (1.0) and SEK2.6 (2.5), respectively. Given a share performance of approximately -1% YTD, Bredband2 is currently trading at an EV/EBIT of approximately 10.7x based on our 2023e and an EV/EBITA of 8.2x.

Investment thesis

Case

Growth through the fibre wave, with subsequent margin expansion

Considering Bredband2’s strong market position in the structural growing fibre market, we believe the company has a solid chance to grow thanks to the fibre wave and the phasing-out of outdated technologies. As Bredband2 is an operator solely with fibre technology and has a scalable, non-cyclical, recurring business, we argue the company is well-positioned to grow sales stable over time with expanded margins. Solid reports and potential acquisitions serve as the key catalysts.

Evidence

Strong market position and scalability support our view

Bredband2 has a clear market position in the Swedish fibre niche, being the no.3 with over 450,000 private customers. Thanks to its strong position in a market where scale matters and a track record of organically expanded customer base and ARPC (average revenues per customer), we see both cross- and up-selling potential to drive future growth. In addition, its history of internal efficiency improvements and scalability hints that growth can derive from minimal cost increases, implying future margin expansion.

Challenge

Intense competition and maturing market

The market is characterised by intense competition, where larger players can cause growth and margin pressure. However, we argue Bredband2 has strengthened its position on the latter, not least through the A3 acquisition in 2020, taking a clear market position. In addition, as selling such a generic product makes customers’ decisions highly price-based, we claim that Bredband2’s low investment needs, internal efficiency and lower price strategy provide a solid competitive advantage.

Challenge

Dependence on network owners

Market players depend highly on the network owners, implying that increased network fees (COGS) can pressure gross margins. At the same time, as customers’ buying decisions are largely price-based, this instead applies gross margin pressure in the other direction. However, Bredband2 has historically managed to offset reduced gross margins superbly by improving its internal efficiency as revenues have grown, thanks to its scalability in OPEX.

Valuation

Low valuation does not reflect its market position

Based on our DCF model, we see a fair value of SEK2.0 per share in our Base Case and SEK1.1 and SEK2.6 per share in our Bear and Bull Cases, respectively. Given Bredband2’s robust market position and potential to capitalise on its substantial customer base, we argue that Bredband2 is well-positioned to grow stable sales over time with future margin expansion. Consequently, we do not believe the current valuation multiples reflect its full potential.

Quality Rating

People: 4

Bredband2 receives a high score for the People rating due to various characteristics based on its management, board members, and owners. The CEO, Daniel Krook, has been in the industry and at the company for a long time and, therefore, has solid market knowledge. Krook has also been at the forefront of the new strategy that has transformed Bredband2 into a profitable growth machine. The company makes well-balanced reinvestments of its stable cash flows but can also distribute money to shareholders. Bredband2 has an active major owner in Anders Lövgren, the chairperson, who holds around c13% of the shares. The rest of the board generally has large shareholdings as well. The CEO owns c1.5% of the company.

Business: 4

Bredband2 receives a high Business rating due to several aspects. Bredband2 is the third-largest fibre player among Swedish consumers and benefits from its positioning in the growing fibre segment in a market where scale matters. Bredband2 has offset gross margins pressure by internal efficiency, which its asset-light business model can explain (low investment needs), not owning the underlying infrastructure, combined with its in-house developed CRM system called BOSS. Furthermore, the recurring revenues and the characteristics of its products being sold give rise to a stable, non-cyclical business with a strong cash conversion.

Financials: 3

Bredband2 receives the actual Financial rating for several reasons. On the positive side, the company has healthy profitability and reliable recurring cash flows that have increased gradually in recent years (customers pay in advance and with low investment needs), supporting its relatively high dividend. Also, we believe its financial position is solid. On the other hand, its gross and EBIT margins are relatively low, and the sales growth rate has decreased in recent years. However, the profitability can increase if the corporate side takes off to a greater extent.

Financials

Income statement
SEKm2020202120222023e2024e
Revenues787.91,511.91,531.41,567.41,609.9
Cost of Revenue529.3978.4995.51,036.61,052.9
Operating Expenses179.2314.0294.6279.1286.1
EBITDA79.4219.5241.3251.7271.0
Depreciation15.315.313.522.522.5
Amortizations21.336.840.933.330.6
EBIT42.893.994.8109.4130.1
Shares in Associates0.000.000.000.000.00
Interest Expenses0.000.0010.511.912.0
Net Financial Items0.000.00-10.5-11.9-12.0
EBT42.384.784.497.5118.1
Income Tax Expenses11.43.511.520.024.3
Net Income30.981.272.977.593.8
Balance sheet
Assets
Non-current assets
SEKm2020202120222023e2024e
Property, Plant and Equipment (Net)32.732.242.044.045.6
Goodwill677.2652.8652.8652.8652.8
Intangible Assets113.3119.2109.275.947.0
Right-of-Use Assets0.00249.4271.7271.7271.7
Other Non-Current Assets47.232.024.224.224.2
Total Non-Current Assets870.31,085.61,099.91,068.61,041.2
Current assets
SEKm2020202120222023e2024e
Inventories6.74.44.45.55.6
Accounts Receivable99.968.667.969.070.8
Other Current Assets51.948.720.223.524.1
Cash Equivalents119.3125.5116.9167.6222.8
Total Current Assets277.7247.1209.4265.6323.4
Total Assets1,148.01,332.81,309.31,334.11,364.6
Equity and Liabilities
Equity
SEKm2020202120222023e2024e
Non Controlling Interest0.000.000.000.000.00
Shareholder's Equity508.9534.7531.0531.9549.7
Non-current liabilities
SEKm2020202120222023e2024e
Long Term Debt102.253.331.731.731.7
Long Term Lease Liabilities0.00149.5166.1166.1166.1
Other Long Term Liabilities32.423.721.021.021.0
Total Non-Current Liabilities134.6226.5218.8218.8218.8
Current liabilities
SEKm2020202120222023e2024e
Short Term Debt48.343.321.721.721.7
Short Term Lease Liabilities0.0082.694.794.794.7
Accounts Payable183.9162.4165.2169.3173.9
Other Current Liabilities272.3283.3277.9297.8305.9
Total Current Liabilities504.5571.6559.5583.4596.1
Total Liabilities and Equity1,148.01,332.81,309.31,334.11,364.6
Cash flow
SEKm2020202120222023e2024e
Operating Cash Flow115.7151.0257.5238.2244.7
Investing Cash Flow-115.1-26.6-53.9-24.4-25.8
Financing Cash Flow-34.9-118.2-212.3-163.0-163.7

Rating definitions

The team

Disclosures and disclaimers

Premium Plan required to unlock

Unlock companies to access

more high quality research.

Contents

Review of Q2 2023

Sales: Slightly stronger than expected

Customer intake, ARPC and gross margin

OPEX: Continue to decrease as a percentage of sales

Profitability: Improved margins that are expected to continue

Estimate changes

Valuation – New Base Case of SEK2.0 (1.9)

Investment thesis

Quality Rating

Financials

Rating definitions

The team

Download article