Enea: Cheap on stable cashflows – and with a kicker

Research Update

2024-02-02

07:00

Redeye was impressed by yet another solid quarter from new-old CEO, Anders Lidbeck, who once again beat estimates on mainly profitabity. Enea also provided a new division between its business units, which Redeye believes will help investors in understanding the company and the investment case. On Redeye's rather modest estimates for 2024e, Enea is trading at 7x free cash flow. Redeye believes that not only is this cheap in itself, but that there are several kickers that could surprise on the upside. Redeye raises its estimates and valuation range.

JVK

RJ

Jesper Von Koch

Rasmus Jacobsson

Contents

Investment thesis

Review of Q4 2023

Top line: Both segments above expectations

Gross margin: Sustained improvement in gross margin

Cost base: cost savings of SEK60m annually complete

Outlook: Targets more than 30% EBITDA margin for 2024

Financial position: balance sheet supports extended buyback program

Changes to financial estimates

Fair value range

Quality Rating

Financials

Rating definitions

The team

Download article

Q4 2023 report supports turnaround view

The EBITDA margin was 37% for the quarter due to higher sales and gross margins than expected - and the full-year adjusted EBITDA margin came in at 34%, supporting the view that Enea’s target of 35% EBITDA margin is achievable. Cash flow was a weak point in the report, but the main reason is higher working capital due to seasonality - something that will likely reverse in the coming quarters.

Moving to realize shareholder value

Enea stated it will update its reporting for 2024 onwards to reflect better Enea's business. Going forward, Enea will group its business into four areas, which we believe will make Enea much easier to understand. In short, we believe this will enable investors and us to group the business into things similar to the Boston Matrix, i.e., incl. "cash cow" (solid profits but slowly dying), "star" (good growth and profitability), "question marks" (big potential but risky), and "dog" (poorly performing). We believe breaking out the segment will increase transparency and increase investor's confidence in Enea's underlying growth.

Also, Enea has extended its buyback program for a third time (Enea already owns 4% of outstanding shares). The extended program allows Enea to repurchase ordinary shares for up to SEK25m (c2% of shares outstanding at SEK54 per share) to and including 24 April 2024. Thus, we view management as taking decisive steps to realize shareholder value.

Shares trade at 7x free cash flow 2024e

The Q4 2023 report adds further evidence of a turnaround story. The cost savings of SEK60m annually is essentially complete. Part of the savings materialize in COGS; thus, we believe Enea can sustain a higher gross margin going forward. Moreover, we have reduced our OPEX estimate by 0-2% for 2024e-2026e due to better-than-expected cost control. Combined changes result in increasing our EBITDA estimates by 18-27% for 2024e-2026e. We increase our fair value range to SEK45-145 with a Base Case of SEK85 from SEK39-123 with a Base Case of SEK75. Considering that we estimate Enea to be trading at 7x FCF for 2024e - and has some upside kickers for substantial growth - we think it is only a matter of time before more investors realize that Enea trades way too cheap.

Key financials

SEKm202220232024e2025e2026e
Revenues959.4912.7896.8969.91,049.9
Revenue Growth-3.4%-4.9%-1.7%8.1%8.2%
EBITDA292.4218.1273.8308.5358.3
EBIT117.9-499.4112.3133.9169.3
EBIT Margin12.3%-54.7%12.5%13.8%16.1%
Net Income203.1-589.470.587.6115.7
EV/Sales2.31.51.41.10.9
EV/EBIT18.6-2.810.98.05.5
EV/EBITDA7.56.54.53.52.6

Investment thesis

Case

Scalable software company with market-leading positions in 5G and cybersecurity - ready for turnaround

Enea, with a rich history in the telecom industry, underwent a significant shift since 2016, transitioning from an Operating Systems software company serving mainly Nokia and Ericsson to a forward-focused business unit called Network Solutions. Specializing in niche software for telecom, including 5G (50-60%) and cybersecurity (40-50%), Enea historically maintained strong EBIT margins exceeding 20% and healthy growth. However, recent years witnessed poor organic growth and declining profitability in Network Solutions, leading to a drop in the share price. With the return of Anders Lidbeck as Interim CEO, there is optimism for a potential turnaround.

Evidence

New-old CEO, Anders Lidbeck, back in the driver's seat - proftiability actions already taken, and growth initiatives are underway

Anders Lidbeck, who led Enea from 2011 to 2019, contributed to the company's high-quality reputation. However, poor operational execution from 2020 to mid-2023 prompted the board (led by Lidbeck) to take decisive action, resulting in the dismissal of the old CEO and Lidbeck stepping in again. In July 2023, an initial cost-savings program of SEK60m per year was announced, with additional savings already implemented. Lidbeck has also enhanced sales efficiency by focusing on high-probability leads. With 40-50% of revenues in Network Solutions coming from cybersecurity, Enea aims to resume growth, even in a low-capex environment for telecom operators.

Supportive Analysis

Historically, customers favored comprehensive solutions from providers like Ericsson. However, there's a shift towards best-of-breed solutions from different providers to create a complete offering. The delay in the 5G Core rollout has slowed this transition, but once it takes off, companies like Enea stand to benefit significantly.

Challenge

Low organic growth in the 'growth leg' and pressure on profitability

Despite facing challenges in transitioning from Operating Systems to Network Solutions, Enea has struggled to achieve significant organic growth in the latter. Acquisitions, despite high valuation multiples, have not yielded substantial results, with organic growth in Network Solutions estimated at around 5% since 2016. The combination of poor organic growth and a gradually expanding cost base led to a trailing 12-month EBIT margin falling below Enea’s 20% target for the first time in years. However, in Q3 2023, even with limited license revenues, the adjusted EBITDA margin reached 34%. Taking into account CAPEX, the underlying cash-flow margin (EBITDA - CAPEX margin) remained healthy at 23%.

Challenge

Uncertainty around the rollout of 5G

Enea states that it will benefit from the change from 4G to 5G - while 5G will drive new income streams, it does not expect 4G revenues to be held up by less developed markets going from 2G or 3G to 4G. Regarding 5G, Enea will participate in the ‘core network’ buildout, which implies the latter part of the rollout. 5G has been substantially delayed compared to industry expectations, so Enea’s 5G investments have not yet paid off. If or when it does, Enea will likely regain its former margins and growth rates.

Valuation

Depressed share price does not include any market tailwind from 5G - nor that cost cuts themselves will lift proftiability

Enea’s share price has sharply dropped from SEK280 to the current SEK57, partly due to a lower-than-expected share of reliable recurring revenue. The current valuation doesn't account for potential 5G-related growth, as Enea’s exposure to 5G core network rollout has just begun. While the company was early in its 5G preparations, macroeconomic factors delayed the rollout. Despite potential 5G delays, the solid base of recurring revenues and implemented cost savings should uplift profitability. Redeye estimates Enea is trading at 11x cash flow (excluding WC changes) for 2024e, a seemingly low valuation for a software company with significant secular tailwinds.

Review of Q4 2023

Net sales revenue was SEK242m, -11% y/y. This was 3% above our estimate of SEK234m. Both segments performed better than expected. Considering that FX effects were more beneficial than we had thought, the underlying performance was in line with our estimates.

EBITDA was SEK88m while adjusting for restructuring costs it reached SEK92m. With investments in intangibles reaching SEK19m, the underlying cash flow (adj. EBITDA-CAPEX) reached SEK73m, well above our estimate of SEK58m. Higher revenue and better gross margins than expected explain the beat.

Enea expects an EBITDA margin above 30% for 2024 and will initiate a new buyback program within the 2023 annual meeting mandate. Overall, the report supports stabilization and the turnaround narrative.

Outcome vs estimates

SEKmQ4'23AQ4'23ELast yearBeat/ Missy/y changeFX adj. Org. Growth
Net sales2422342713%-11%-13%
- of which Network Solutions2132072373%-10%-12%
- of which Operating Systems2927346%-16%
Gross margin79%76%76%3pp3pp
EBITDA897710315%-14%
EBIT43355823%-25%

Top line: Both segments above expectations

Network Solutions: New categorization of revenues to come in 2024

Network Solutions accounted for 88% of sales in the quarter. Sales decreased by 10% y/y. Currency-adjusted organic growth for the quarter was -12%. Support and maintenance grew y/y while licensing and professional services decreased.

Management will update its reporting starting in 2024 to reflect Enea’s security, networks, and other portfolios. We expect this to improve visibility for the cyber security segment.

Due to the seasonal pattern in Network Solutions, with Q2 typically being bigger than Q1, Q3 bigger than Q2, and Q4 bigger than Q3, we provide a quarterly comparison diagram below.

Enea: Network Solutions

Source: Enea

Network Solutions: Revenue per type

Licensing revenues landed at SEK87.9m, down from last year's SEK105.5m. Support & maintenance grew 7% y/y. Sequentially, all segments grew between 2% and 19%, as expected from the seasonal pattern.

The revenue mix of the included parts of Network Solutions can be seen below:

Enea: Network Solutions, revenue per type (SEKm)

Source: Enea

Operating Systems: Key accounts below 50%

Sales from Operating Systems continued to decline. Sales came in at SEK28.5m, corresponding to a y/y drop of 16%, or -17% currency adjusted. This continuous drop is expected as customers introduce open-source software for new products. The decline was however smaller than we had anticiated.

Enea: Operating Systems

Source: Enea

Gross margin: Sustained improvement in gross margin

The gross margin landed at 79% (excluding “other operating income”), compared to 75% for the full year 2022 and 76% in the last quarter. Enea has completed its cost savings program of SEK60m annually on a cash basis. Part of the savings affect COGS. Thus, we expect gross margins to be higher going forward.

Enea: Gross margin

Source: Enea

The seasonal pattern of license revenues being stronger the farther into the financial year implies that Q1 will have a much higher share of service revenue (with a lower gross margin) than all other quarters, especially compared to Q4. To illustrate the seasonality, see the below diagram for the same figures:

Enea: Quarterly y/y comparison of gross margin

Source: Enea

Cost base: cost savings of SEK60m annually complete

Reported OPEX, incl. D&A, was SEK147.5m, and “clean” OPEX (excl. D&A) was SEK101.7m. “Other operating income” consists of revaluation of the incentive program and FX-related revaluations of accounts receivable, meaning that we consider this a one-off. Adjusting for the "one-off" write-downs and restructuring costs, EBITDA was SEK92.2m, with an adj. EBITDA margin of 38%, comfortably above the EBITDA target of 35%. According to management, efficiency implementations have improved cash savings to just over SEK60m annually. Thus, we view the restructuring as essentially complete.

Enea: OPEX

Source: Enea

Outlook: Targets more than 30% EBITDA margin for 2024

Enea reiterated its financial targets of double-digit sales growth in its focus areas and an EBITDA margin above 35%. The EBITDA margin was 37% in Q4 2023. The full-year EBITDA margin was 24%. EBITDA margin adjusted for non-recurring expenses was 38% in Q4 2023. The full-year adjusted EBITDA margin was 32%. While Enea expects growth to be constrained by customers’ willingness to invest, it expects to achieve strong cash flow and an EBITDA margin above 30% for 2024.

Financial position: balance sheet supports extended buyback program

Net debt/EBITDA at 1.0x

Total debt decreased SEK9m sequentially while cash decreased by SEK71m. Thus, net debt increased by SEK62m sequentially. The main reason is higher working capital and cash outlay for buybacks. Working capital increased due to seasonality and increased accounts receivables in the quarter.

Capital allocation: Extended buyback program for a third time

Enea has extended its buyback program for a third time. The extended program allows Enea to repurchase ordinary shares for up to SEK25m but not more than 10% of the shares outstanding for the period up to and including 24 April 2024. This translates to about 2% of the shares outstanding at the current share price.

Changes to financial estimates

  • We keep our net sales estimate intact and make no changes to the sales estimates for either segment.
  • We increase our gross margin expectations between 1-4 percentage points.
  • We lower OPEX estimates by 0-2%.
  • Our changes result in a 4-7 percentage point increase in EBITDA margin and a 4-7% increase in our EBIT margin forecast.
  • In our 2024e, Enea surpasses its EBITDA target of above 30% by 1 percentage point.

Estimate changes

SEKm20212022Q1 23Q2 23Q3 23Q4 2320232024E2025E2026E
Total net sales994959248208216242913
New8979701050
Old8979701050
Change0%0%0%
Gross margin79%75%80%70%76%79%76%
New77%77%78%
Old75%75%76%
Change3%3%3%
OPEX434463109191101103501
New419440463
Old417452489
Change0%-3%-5%
EBITDA37529294-366889218
New274308358
Old23925841
Change14%20%24%
EBIT21411847-6061643-499
New112134169
Old6988119
Change62%53%42%
EBIT (%)22%12%19%-292%7%18%-55%
New13%14%16%
Old8%9%11%
Change5%5%5%

Estimate changes per business segment

SEKm20212022Q1 23Q2 23Q3 23Q4 2320232024E2025E2026E
Network Solutions727802164182193213751
New804885973
Old804885211
Change0%0%0%
Operating Systems13712684262329162
New928577
Old928517
Change0%0%0%

Financial estimates overview

SEKm20212022Q1 23Q2 23Q3 23Q4 2320232024E2025E2026E
Net sales9949592482082162429138979701,050
- Network Solutions727802164182193213751804885973
- Operating Systems13712684262329162928577
EBITDA37529294-366889218274308358
EBIT21411847-6061643-499112134169
EPS (SEK)9.249.290.47-28.40.350.60-27.673.314.115.43
EBITDA - CAPEX24816464-575070129163189229
Growth (%)7%-3%2%-4%-6%-11%-5%-2%8%8%
Gross margin79%75%80%70%76%79%76%77%77%78%
EBITDA margin (%)38%30%38%-17%32%37%24%31%32%34%
EBIT margin (%)22%12%19%-292%7%18%-55%13%14%16%
EBITDA-CAPEX margin (%)25%17%26%-28%23%29%14%18%19%22%
Net income margin (%)20%11%4%-299%4%5%-65%8%9%11%

Fair value range

Assumptions, fair value range
Bear CaseBase caseBull case
Value per share, SEK4585145
CAGR 2022-2027 per segment
Network Solutions3%5%7%
Operating Systems-13%-11%-9%
Total1%3%5%
Total sales 20271,0431,2111,401
EBIT margin 202713%16%21%
Avg EBIT margin 2023-202712%15%19%
Terminal EBIT margin9%16%21%

Quality Rating

People: 4

The Board has extensive experience in telecom and software. The interim CEO, Anders Lidbeck, led Enea in the years between 2011 to 2019 - making the company being viewed as highly qualitative. Poor operatonal execution between 2020 and the first half of 2023 then caused Enea's board of directors (led by Mr. Lidbeck) to take firm action - leading to dismissing the old CEO and letting Lidbeck stepping in once again. We think highly of Lidbeck's excecution skills.

Per Lindberg, Enea's main owner (34% of total shares), has a deep understanding of the telecom industry. However, Management and the Board do not own enough shares as they together do not even control 1% of the company. On the top 10 owners, we find several reputable institutions, though. Enea has since 2016 made approximately one acquisition per year. While Enea has paid quite hefty valuation multiples, the growth rate since these acquisitions has been in close to non-existing. This puts a question mark on capital allocation skills.

Business: 4

The markets for RTOS as well as DPI, video optimization, and policy and access control, are mirroring the strong growth of data traffic from 5G and the increased number of connected devices. While Network Data Layer holds significant potential, this market is awaiting the rollout of 5G Core networks. Enea is the number one player in its niche telecom markets: RTOS, DPI, and mobile video.

Enea has a solid breadth of its producs portfolio of ten different products, and serving more than 100 customers. Through the acquisitions of Qosmos, Openwave, Atos, Aptilo and AdaptiveMobile Security, Enea has market-leading positions in its various niches in Telecom and Cybersecurity.

While Enea states that more than 50% of its revenue base is recurring, we find its predictability to be low.

Financials: 3

For the first time in many years, the trailing-12-month EBIT margin does not exceed Enea's 20% target. While Enea has gone through a tough transition period, moving from Operating Systems to Network Solution, we are not impressed by Enea's organic growth. Since 2016, we assess this to have been around 5%. Also, the company's revenue base has become bumpy and unpredictable due to a lower share of recurring license revenues. For a higher rating, we need a clearer way towards organic growth in the high single digits, at least.

Financials

Income statement
SEKm202220232024e2025e2026e
Revenues959.4912.7896.8969.91,049.9
Cost of Revenue241.6215.0204.5221.2228.9
Operating Expenses425.4479.6418.6440.2462.7
EBITDA292.4218.1273.8308.5358.3
Depreciation12.414.017.919.421.0
Amortizations146.8690.1143.5155.2168.0
EBIT117.9-499.4112.3133.9169.3
Shares in Associates0.000.000.000.000.00
Interest Expenses31.767.823.523.523.5
Net Financial Items-17.3-67.8-23.5-23.5-23.5
EBT100.6-567.288.8110.4145.7
Income Tax Expenses-7.422.218.322.730.0
Net Income203.1-589.470.587.6115.7
Balance sheet
Assets
Non-current assets
SEKm202220232024e2025e2026e
Property, Plant and Equipment (Net)21.518.518.518.518.5
Goodwill1,737.11,304.21,304.21,304.21,304.2
Intangible Assets719.6540.4507.3471.5432.7
Right-of-Use Assets37.138.438.438.438.4
Other Non-Current Assets25.915.315.315.315.3
Total Non-Current Assets2,541.31,916.81,883.71,847.91,809.1
Current assets
SEKm202220232024e2025e2026e
Inventories0.000.000.000.000.00
Accounts Receivable545.4402.5493.3484.9524.9
Other Current Assets0.000.000.000.000.00
Cash Equivalents231.3261.8369.4523.0661.5
Total Current Assets776.7664.3862.61,008.01,186.4
Total Assets3,318.02,581.12,746.32,855.92,995.6
Equity and Liabilities
Equity
SEKm202220232024e2025e2026e
Non Controlling Interest0.000.000.000.000.00
Shareholder's Equity2,295.71,683.71,754.21,841.81,957.5
Non-current liabilities
SEKm202220232024e2025e2026e
Long Term Debt543.2470.9470.9470.9470.9
Long Term Lease Liabilities23.422.322.322.322.3
Other Long Term Liabilities135.2110.4110.4110.4110.4
Total Non-Current Liabilities701.8603.6603.6603.6603.6
Current liabilities
SEKm202220232024e2025e2026e
Short Term Debt6.6276.5269.1291.0315.0
Short Term Lease Liabilities14.517.317.317.317.3
Accounts Payable21.60.000.000.000.00
Other Current Liabilities277.70.00102.2102.2102.2
Total Current Liabilities320.4293.8388.6410.5434.5
Total Liabilities and Equity3,318.02,581.12,746.32,855.92,995.6
Cash flow
SEKm202220232024e2025e2026e
Operating Cash Flow253.0146.1235.9292.5288.7
Investing Cash Flow-128.8-102.9-128.3-138.8-150.2
Financing Cash Flow0.000.000.000.000.00

Rating definitions

The team

Disclosures and disclaimers

Premium Plan required to unlock

Unlock companies to access

more high quality research.

Contents

Investment thesis

Review of Q4 2023

Top line: Both segments above expectations

Gross margin: Sustained improvement in gross margin

Cost base: cost savings of SEK60m annually complete

Outlook: Targets more than 30% EBITDA margin for 2024

Financial position: balance sheet supports extended buyback program

Changes to financial estimates

Fair value range

Quality Rating

Financials

Rating definitions

The team

Download article